You must have Javascript enabled to view this content.

i need some better starters or at least some more diversity because pitching with someone like bumgardener every other game is kind of annoying. Main question: who is been pitching well for you guys that isn’t like kershaw or something 

8/25/2019 8:12AM PDT

jack morris wasnt bad for me, im kind of in the same boat though

8/25/2019 8:13AM PDT

Love Fergie. He is a steal at his stub cost. 

8/25/2019 8:30AM PDT

Kershaw, Morris, Fergie. Thinking of getting Oswalt back in my rotation, not many starters I like. Chris Sale is always fun even with his now nerfed stats.

8/25/2019 8:34AM PDT

its late August and the last thing I want to do is pitch with Kershaw or Ryan, so my latest rotation I’ve been running is 

Fellar 

Blyleven 

Price 

Fergie 

Grienke 

With a slight rotation of Gibson as the 6th man so I don’t get the same SP twice 

8/25/2019 9:27AM PDT

After all this time, I’m still unable to take Hershiser out of my rotation 

8/25/2019 9:36AM PDT

I still love Nolan but I get bored pitching with kershaw for sure 

8/25/2019 12:20PM PDT

Blyleven has been my fav pitcher this year, even with the few starts ive gotten to use him. (All in below 700)

8/25/2019 12:36PM PDT

Another vote for Fergie, only used him once so far in RS but 9 ip 5 H 13 K performance on allstar has me sold

8/25/2019 12:41PM PDT

I’m still rocking Cy Young as my ace. 

8/25/2019 2:54PM PDT

My 5 man is Gibson, Keyshawn, Ryan, Madbum, and Waino.

I know you dislike Madbum - but he’s been dominant for me in 2-3 starts, Waino ain’t bad as a number 5, & Gibson has been much better for me than others.

I’m looking for a 6th to add in like others have..I struggled with Greinke in a few starts, and got lit up in my first appearance with Bert. So I’m still looking... 

Saberhagen can be filthy at times for me (also might be my favorite pitcher as a Royals fan). 

8/25/2019 6:41PM PDT

I love using Castillo... hes cheap and really good for me... I mean cy young and bob Gibson are good too but if u want a cheap and good pitcher Castillo is the way to go.

8/25/2019 7:16PM PDT

i need some better starters or at least some more diversity because pitching with someone like bumgardener every other game is kind of annoying. Main question: who is been pitching well for you guys that isn’t like kershaw or something 

Comment by jrMURF
8/25/2019 8:12AM PDT

Bob Gibson and Bumgardner have been my 2 best pitchers this year.

8/25/2019 7:18PM PDT

I loved Prior from day 1 and hasn't left my rotation since

8/25/2019 7:19PM PDT

My 5 man is Gibson, Keyshawn, Ryan, Madbum, and Waino.

I know you dislike Madbum - but he’s been dominant for me in 2-3 starts, Waino ain’t bad as a number 5, & Gibson has been much better for me than others.

I’m looking for a 6th to add in like others have..I struggled with Greinke in a few starts, and got lit up in my first appearance with Bert. So I’m still looking... 

Saberhagen can be filthy at times for me (also might be my favorite pitcher as a Royals fan). 

Comment by tonyc149
8/25/2019 6:41PM PDT

Must have missed the SS Keyshawn Johnson 

8/25/2019 8:09PM PDT

I’ve tried virtually every single diamond pitcher on here and in my opinion, the best 5 are:

1. 98 Blyleven 1.23 ERA 263.2 IP

2. 99 Kershaw 2.09 ERA 396.2 IP

3. 96 Cy Young 1.91 ERA 301.1 IP

4. 97 Jenkins 2.02 ERA 62.1 IP

5. 95 Hunter 2.73 ERA 66 IP

Honorable mention 90 Sutton 1.98 ERA 300.2 IP

Forget 99 Feller, 99 Grove, 99 Gibson 99 Verlander, they all either get rocked or have control issues. 96 Felix Hernandez most overrated pitcher on here performance and cost wise. I even have 99 Ryan out of rotation because his control is straight garbage.

Just as important, you need strong bullpen.

8/25/2019 9:11PM PDT

I love using Castillo... hes cheap and really good for me... I mean cy young and bob Gibson are good too but if u want a cheap and good pitcher Castillo is the way to go.

Comment by BostonSlugger33
8/25/2019 7:16PM PDT

Ridiculous sample size of one game, but I absolutely rolled over some dude with Castillo. I need to try him some more. Whether he sticks in my rotation or not, he's a steal.

8/25/2019 11:38PM PDT
...

Must have missed the SS Keyshawn Johnson 

Comment by Therealest_JB
8/25/2019 8:09PM PDT

Haha whoops, auto correct I guess? 

8/26/2019 6:22AM PDT

93 Arrieta can be very useful, currently my #5 and about 40k stubs

8/26/2019 7:39AM PDT

Ford and Hershiser

8/26/2019 8:58AM PDT

Join the conversation

Please login here to join the conversation.