I'm thinking that maybe this could develop into a thread within which people point out ratings which seem at odds with reality, giving the developers a quick reference spot. Who knows?
Anyway, the one that I saw which sparked my interest in starting this thread is quite glaring: 75 Fielding for... Manny Machado at 3B? Say what? He's already one of the best defensive third basemen in history and is certainly the best defensive third baseman in the current Major Leagues.
I think they screwed with some of the numbers both on offense and defense to keep overall ratings relative.
If Arenado or Machado have more defense attributes would their overall be higher? Just a thought.