just went 3-3 with 3 no doubters vs me in an event. Anyone else getting mashed or mashing with him?
Pujols’ first ten years are slightly better than Thomas’ best ten year stretch for hitting only (which I think is ‘91 to 2000). And if you included baserunning to get an overall offensive value, Pujols was better by a larger margin. Thomas will end up with better rate statistics for offense over their entire careers because Pujols has taken a hatchet to those the last few years. But he had a slightly better ten year peak for hitting, a better peak for overall offensive value, and a much better peak and career for overall value with defense included.