You must have Javascript enabled to view this content.

In your opinion who is the best pitcher to have been in The Show?

12 days ago 1 Like

I gotta go with 93 Future Stars Alex Reyes.  That card was absolutely filthy.  Behind him I'd say 2016s Angels Nolan Ryan.

12 days ago

Immortal Seaver 

17 Vida

17 99 Hershiser

17 99 Verlander 

12 days ago

I loved using the Future Stars Walker Buhler from 17.

But i'd have to agree, 17 Vida Blue was nasty.

Show Replies
12 days ago
This comment has been deleted.
12 days ago

17 Vida and Scott

18 (non-immortals) PS Orel and Sutton

12 days ago

17 Vida and PS Hersheiser

18 iSeaver and iKershaw 

i will never give knucklers the best pitcher award 

12 days ago

17 Vida Blue and Orel Hershiser were filthy for me

11 days ago

Tim Wakefield

11 days ago

17 Vida and PS Hersheiser

18 iSeaver and iKershaw 

i will never give knucklers the best pitcher award 

Comment by doobiebross66-72
about 12 hours ago

Lol, as soon as I saw Steven Wright had been suspended 80 games for PED's I was thinking, I wish he could be suspended on The Show as well.

11 days ago

‘17 Vida. I’m not a great player by any means but to date my greatest accomplishment is a one hit shutout I got with him in RS. One of many great games with him, dude was unfair.

10 days ago

17 vida blue dude gives me nightmares.